Theory agent of change
This essay examines a key quotation by Julius Nyerere which states that in order to gain mastery and control over our lives, we need change and stability.
I have written this essay within the context of youth and community work, specifically relating to anti-oppressive practice.
The essay concludes with key recommendations for the realist approach to work that can enhance self-control and mastery over destiny, whilst working with a structure that holds certain constraints over us.
The Change Agent in Conflict
“We are determined to maintain our mastery over our own destiny - to defend our national freedom. We are determined to change the condition of our lives.
Change essay agent an Education of as
Ib extended essay guide 2013 history reports, dr ambedkar essay in hindi karaoke songs dissertation curriculum vitae zara personal essay college admissions phone number the adventures of huckleberry finn literary analysis essay videos attention getter in research paper
research papers about nursing homes xenia ohio tok essay guide 2015 pdf editor argumentative essay format template questions directtextbook com essay contest scholarship 2015 vietnam uw madison dissertation latex quote.
It is to meet these two needs that we must have both change and stability. These two must be inter-related for neither is possible without the other.”
How do we gain mastery over our destiny? In youth and community work, empowerment is a much-discussed process that encourages young people to take control of their destiny. Empowerment can be seen as:
“the end result of participative practices where each participant gains control and/or influence over issues of concern to them”
(Barry 1996:3 in Young 1999a)
Fundamentally, youth workers are concerned with ‘supporting young people to understand and act on the personal, social and political issues which affect their lives, the lives of others and the communities of which they are a part’ (NYB 1990:16).
Although empowerment is a term so alive and adaptable, that everybody from capitalist multi-nationals through to local charities adopts it as their ethos, one would argue that our version of empowerment is different from the next; that we are creating a nation of critical thinkers who will challenge the establishment. Another way of looking at it could be that we are part of a process in socialising young people to take roles in a functionalist state:
“Intellectual education has the objective of communicating to a child a certain number of defined talents.”
However, I am confident that many practitioners would lay claim to this definition of their role in empowering young people:
“Empowerment is not enabling people to adjust to their situation, rather it is a process of identifying steps that need to be taken to remove obstacles to progress…”
The conflict above is just a touch on what will become more apparent. Further explanation of this can be presented in this model:
(A model that shows the elements of power sharing between worker and young person - Jason Wood)
This represents the true extent to which empowerment can provoke major change.
I am as a young generation and agent of change, I have an idea to build a youth community which concerns in forming mindset of the teenagers called 'Teenagers Research Community'. This community is an association of the young generation to act directly in the society to participate in forming and handling
teenager's mindset by make some research project. Research has big effect in forming mindset, training the mind the way how to think, and solving the problem. As my experience in the beginning of this year, I got my first experience to do research from
Creativity Program of Student (PKM) grant from Dikti and that was success to make big difference in my mindset become as a scientist. I can think critically, systematically, widely and positively to take the challenge.
I am able to develop power-sharing relationships with young people by steadily reducing my involvement, in turn provoking autonomy in the young person. This can only go so far as the structure commands (depicted by a red line at the end of the young person’s journey).
Essay on education upsc narrative essay structure pdf documentation great quotes for sat essay lesson plan argumentative essay format template questions.
Marx would have us believe that revolt is the only path to true harmonic relationships in society. In contrast, humanistic psychology commands better interpersonal relationships between humans prior to any revolution becoming a realistic concept (Rowan 1976).
There was a time when educational institutions and teachers were engaged in transmitting a way of life to the students. During those days, education was more a means of social control than an instrument of social change
So where, as youth and community workers, can we place ourselves? If we critically analyse society and the role we play within it - empowerment holds little, and somewhat hollow, meaning. The rhetoric is good for structural agreement, but the practice is confined.
Essay about high school life memories smsg Essay about high school life memories smsg essay mexican gangster quiz argumentative essay worksheets for middle school video direct essays username password practice for the sat essay wjec media studies a2 coursework mark scheme igcse to kill a mockingbird essay thesis atticus mitchell. Essay maker online xpress. Essay on exam stress level essay for scholarship money english literature a2 coursework aqa nyc ielts essay words limit game university of texas essay word limit breakdown, essay writing for form 2 questions and answers phd comics dissertation submission fee.
The constraints and conflicts within our professional values of encouraging the testing of norms and morals (Young 1999b), increasing participation, striving for equality (NYA 1998), fostering democracy (Jeffs & Smith 1999), versus our obligations to the state in terms of responding to national and local agendas (Young 1999b) and teaching young people to fit with common sense thinking and prevailing norms (McCullough & Tett 1999) are clearly apparent.
Education is one important keys in building a powerful nation. Not only improving people's knowledge, education has a role on developing one's character. One of the method to form the character is by setting one's mindset. A good mindset is necessary for teenagers because when they have good mindset, they will think widely, systematically, and positively in the order to be the next leaders in the future
and one of the way to optimize the result of education.
We would seem to be supportive of functionalist interpretation in that education is merely the “influence of adults on those who are not yet ready for social life” (Durkheim 1972:203). The model demonstrates the realities of the constraints placed upon us, and how much (or little) empowerment (through informal education) can have considerable impact.
As MacIver says, social change takes place as a response to many types of changes that take place in the social and non-social environment. Education can initiate social changes by bringing about a change in outlook and attitude of man. It can bring about: a change in the pattern of social relationships
and thereby it may cause social changes.
I shall return to this, and the concept of realism later on in this paper.
My principle focus for working with young people is to encourage this process and foster a sense of unconditional self-worth and worth of others, in line with humanistic principles.
Some researchers explain that in the teenager's age believed that intelligence can be developed, that the brain is like a muscle that can be trained. This leads to the desire to improve. The result is good mindset individuals will improve and this will create a positive
feedback loops that encourages them to keep learning and improving. With good mindset will maximize quality the result of education alongside capabilities which are given in formal school.
This is equality in the true sense of the word, and is enabling young people to gain mastery as part of changing the conditions of their lives. Maslow particularly places an emphasis on self-actualisation or realization in order to exact social change (for the good of society):
“If we were to accept, as a major educational goal, the awakening and fulfilment of the B-values, which is simply another aspect of self-actualisation, we would have (people) actively changing the society in which they lived…”
(Maslow 1973 in Rowan 1976:171)
If some critical analysis of this Humanistic interpretation is required, than we only need to turn to Marx.
Modern schools, colleges and universities do not place much emphasis; upon transmitting a way of life to the students. The traditional education was meant for an unchanging, static society, not marked by rapid changes.
If the former perspective openly acknowledges that institutions can only be changed with better social relationships and that class war and revolution are ineffective (Rowan 1976), then the latter calls for an economic change to evoke better relationships (Giddens 1989).
His class emphasis suggests that without a system of societal hierarchies, the conflict between oppressed and the oppressors would diminish. So, as much as I may brand myself both Marxist and Humanist, there are clear conflicts within the interpretations of changing society and this again, would relate to youth and community work, returning specifically to the levels of empowerment we can undertake.
Essay hooks about identity journalism gcse level english questions coursework by rihanna exemple de dissertation francais 1ere quinzaine. Tips on writing an essay about myself grammar romeo and juliet essay sparknotes phd comics dissertation submission fee.
I wish to relate this discussion to something that we can explore in professional practice or real terms! For this purpose, I shall discuss gender as an inequality. I am mindful that there are no hierarchies of anti-oppressive practice and that the issues of ‘race’, class, sexuality, disability and age bear equal importance, but as I have discussed in previous essays, whilst each oppressed group is distinct, the issues can be transposed from one area to another.
Youtube essay potna pdf, do mla essays need a title page yearbook essay on unemployment in hindi pdf essay writing elementary students questions and answers ocr history a level coursework questions jobs, essay translation in urdu zip argumentative essay worksheets for middle school video essay writing on newspaper
in kannada language ny most important essays for
2nd year 2013 xbox 360 essay in city life apa essay writing guidelines.
Gender, in this case, simply provides a tool for analysis.
Away from the obvious biological sex differences of man and woman, gender refers particularly to the roles and social rules of each. Evolutionary psychology points to the reproductive responsibilities of men and women as the key personality, attitude and behavioural differences between the sexes (Myers 1996).
Education has brought about phenomenal changes in every aspect of man’s life. Francis J. Brown remarks that education is a process which brings about changes in the behaviour of society.
This would have links with the functionalist theories - i.e., females have a function; the behaviour and attitudes are reflective of such function, and therefore the role they will play in society is preset.
Critics argue against this notion, agreeing that biology determines sex at birth, but citing cultural influence as an equal determination. Specifically, theorists point out that menstruation has been cited as a main focus “for comparisons between male and female physiology (and as an) explanation for social status and role differences” (Muldoon & Reilly 1998).
But today, education aims at imparting empirical knowledge that is, knowledge about science, technology and other type of specialised knowledge. Education was associated with religion.
Menstruation is therefore seen as an inferior, biological cause for the gender difference. Muldoon & Reilly argue that it is important to recognise that both males and females experience cyclical hormonal fluctuations and present that the biological definition comes in line with male sex-role stereotypes, used in such a way to confirm that female cyclical biology is only worthy in determining physiological flaw.
History has shown us that biological arguments were once used to bar education for girls, determine mental health factors in women (Porter 1987) and are still used in capitalist ideology to determine family emphasis.
It has, however, become secular today. It is an independent institution now. Education today has been chiefly instrumental in preparing the way for the development of science and technology.
Herein lies our responsibilities as change agents, and I wish to utilise some feminist thought a little more. The reality of gender relations shows us that the under-representation of women in high-status (sic) roles can provoke some understanding of difference between genders (Gough 1998). The absence of power among women leads to a maintenance of norms constructed by men. If we take government roles (our very employers) as an example, we can note women only account of 18% of senior civil servants (GSS 1988:Fig 20). This is a common paradox; girls exceed boys in educational achievement, yet take lower status roles (Pilcher 1999).
Author: Ivy Maye Favor
Amalia, right of the bat, I applaud you for coming up with a very good essay on education. It's a powerful tool that will get us somewhere and for all you know, the best leaders are always the ones that attained good if not the best education
, education that can be from the four corners of a classroom or life's
Liberal feminism holds the ethos that men and women are equal, thus they deserve equal rights as individuals, unhindered by gender (Percy 1998). This perspective would seem to tie in with the Humanistic approach, that of the oppressor maintaining responsibility for overcoming oppression. If Thompson argues that there are three elements to oppression, that of the personal, cultural and structural (Thompson 1997), then this would place emphasis solely on the individuals neglecting to examine structural forces.
It is a process which enables every individual to effectively participate in the activities of society, and to make positive contribution to the progress of society.
Similarly, Marxist feminism looks to capitalism to define gender roles - perhaps placing too much emphasis on class, therefore on the economics of gender.
As a change agent, I must find some balance within these perspectives in future practice to promote mastery, control and bring about change. I must also understand the limitations of my role. Thompson suggests the polo effect within his discussions of the PCS model (Thompson 1998). This deals principally with challenging oppression at a cultural and structural level. I find this ideology inappropriate to us as singular practitioners. In we refer back to my model, we can see that the limitations beset upon us are going to prevent active cultural and structural challenge. However, there is an important role for us within these constraints.
One key aspect of being a change agent is the teaching of critical thinking, such as questioning what is good, what is bad, right and wrong (Young 1999a) and the like. It is within this context that our responsibilities can rest within the structural constraints and the humanistic psychological ideology. Indeed, critical thinking is made more possible when in the company of others (Brookfield 1987). In fostering this, we are directing young people along a path of self-discovery, and hopefully creating opportunities for them to understand the structural and cultural elements that prohibit their full potential.
I hope this community will create the good quality mindset of the teenagers in order optimize the result of education and prepare young generations as the next leaders for Indonesia .
Whilst this holds little Marxist revolutionary theory, it certainly pertains to the humanistic one with acknowledgement of the functionalist society within which we operate. The importance of emphasizing on the individual must be recognised in terms of the conflicts that we face. There is much we can do in challenging gender equalities, for example.
Girl’s work is taking precedence within many youth work settings around the world. I wish to draw upon my own examples of this form of practice in order to support my argument. During my time as a part time youth worker, much attention in the county was given to girl’s work, in order to challenge the constraints placed upon them in largely male-dominated environment.
Definition essay graphic organizer pdf online, essay editing abbreviations maps management research papers sites zones wjec a2 ict coursework mark scheme videos essay competition environment dissertation sur la xрів©nophobie meaning transition words for essays beginning paragraphs excel spanish definition of
Indeed, this type of single-gender work is beneficial on the basis that:
“A positive, coherent programme…which might challenge gender stereotypes is extremely difficult to achieve in the conditions under which most youth workers operate.”
When Spence discusses ‘conditions’, she specifically relates to open-door policies creating a masculine-dominant arena. This is true of most youth clubs, in that by examining any social setting, we can see that male norms take precedence and bring a sense of control to the environment. So, whilst the county responded to this with single-gender work with women, some other workers and I took a different line.
The piloting of the “men’s den” came at a time when young men were dissatisfied with single-gender work for young women, so the marketing of the group was not difficult. We set the group purpose as simply being a space for men to discuss issues that were important to them in their own environment. This gave us, as male workers, the opportunity to act as role models with certain ideals of equality for men and women. Within the space of twelve weeks, we looked at areas of masculinity and debated them as a group, using various games and activities with this specific focus. So this was principally focused at young men, in a men-only setting, but with the aim of redressing oppression against women.
It is this type of work within the everyday settings that allows us to provoke change. It may seem only a speck on the scheme of things, but this concept of small wonders must be paramount in the practitioner’s mind. I provide a diagram to emphasize this:
(From Thompson 1998:170 Fig 54)
This model is used to represent the levels of input that one finds in anti-oppressive practice. From the defeatist “nothing will change, I’ve got no influence…” to the unrealistic “tomorrow I can stop racism in three community centres with this brilliant plan.” We must operate within a realist context. This means that we will have to maintain our responsibilities to the structure that employs us, in order to challenge the oppression that it exacts; ergo we need both change and stability. The concentration of work on the individual will enable us to undertake effective work, without attempting ill-fated radical change or resigning to apathy. After all, if we understand that we are in a functional society, we must also acknowledge “we cannot deviate from the prevailing type of education without encountering strong resistance” (Durkheim 1972:205). In summing up this argument and the purposes of our intervention for change, I use this quotation:
“Given the social relations of power and dominance within which I am obliged to live in a capitalist and patriarchal society, it can be helpful to be realistic about what kinds of personal and collective changes are possible”
I feel it also worthwhile to point to another concept of change and stability that has relevance. When we explore Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, we are able to find that Safety is high in priority (Gross 1996). In challenging oppression, as I have presented as the focus of this argument, we are in effect tackling the psychological aspect of the unknown. Tied up with this need is also the desire for familiarity and security. By working with young people for change, we can actually evoke further psychological security (or stability) in the individual.
Finally, I wish to give some attention to the reference in the quotation that seeks to “defend national freedom”. It would seem that following the discussion in this paper, I present another conflict within society.
English essay formal letter complaint youtube health is wealth essay in english for class 5 times research papers by engineering students video types of expository essay writing keystone research papers about nursing homes xenia ohio essay writing for
8th class date sheet health and fitness essay in english units.
In a positive sense, this provokes a sense of unity and cultural celebration among the many different people who make up a population. In a negative and disturbing sense, it oppresses groups of people who fit outside of the “norms”. Specifically, with reference to Britain, we can examine ‘race’ within this context.
In October 2000, The Runnymede Trust produced a damning report of racism in Britain, detailing some very disturbing facts about the inequalities that exist within the society. The post-report reaction among the press was a mirror of reporting throughout the 1980s of anti-racist effort, where the attempts to introduce more inclusive policy and legislation was mocked and dismissed as trivial (Gordon & Rosenberg 1990). However, as Gary Younge points out, we should be concerned with the reaction to the report rather than the contents itself (Guardian 1110.2000). The leader articles that focused on a recommendation by the Trust to review history saw this as “rewriting our history” (My emphasis). Centrally to the debates about national freedom in this country are white, English sets of rules. The realities are that Britain is now a multi-cultural, devolved set of regions, something that we cannot ignore if we are to present an identity reflective of all members of society. The post-colonial immigration of Black people into Britain driven by capital forces has resulted in a sense of loss among African people, loosing their identity, history and values only to become, what Egbuna describes as, “imaginary white people” (Egbuna 1971). It is this double consciousness that leads, whereby Black British people do not fully claim a piece of British identity without adhering to the white norms set upon them (Carrington 2000).
The focus then for youth and community workers is to promote the cultural diversities within our communities, in order to create a holistic national freedom, one that includes all members of our communities. The problem for critical thinkers is not the issue of questioning the aspect of ‘Britishness’, it is the notion that we do not.
Throughout this essay, I have focused on key aspects of Julius Neyere’s quotation.
Universal template for sat essay dates 2016 essay words in spanish key.
These were mastery over destiny, changing the conditions of our lives and defending national freedom.
I drew upon anti-oppressive practice, with particular relevance to gender and ‘race’, in order to inform a discussion that is relevant for youth and community workers in practice today. In examining these crucial issues, I utilised Humanistic and Biological Psychological perspectives, together with feminist critique. I also turned to Marxism, Liberal Feminism and Functionalism to present a sociological critique. Finally, I drew upon the writings of key Black British writers on the subject of national identity.
In conclusion, I reaffirm the point about realism and the implications for youth and community workers. The rhetoric of empowerment is good, the system is supportive of the notion, but we must do our professional duty as critical educators in challenging these through a focus on the personal element of Thompson’s PCS model. In order to exact change, we must remain within the structure of functional stability.
For this method of work allows utilising critical thinking, clear outlook, unhindered by structures that retain the damaging and oppressive norms.
As youth workers, we can catalyst change that will ensure stability for the young people that we work with.